Nadine Matheson: To All the Serial Killers I’ve Loved Before

It seems almost serendipitous that in the week that my book The Jigsaw Man is released, we’re also celebrating the 30th anniversary of the film The Silence of the Lambs. Both the book and the film set a new standard for not only crime fiction but also our dysfunctional love affair with the serial killer. We’re both enthralled, appalled and excited by serial killers and even though we may not admit it; we all have our favourites. So, who takes the top four spots in my exclusive club of fictional serial criminals?

Hannibal Lecter

I first met the renowned psychiatrist, Dr. Hannibal Lecter when I was 14 years old. Instead of reading the required text of An Inspector Calls for GCSE English, I carried out my small act of rebellion, by reading The Silence of The Lambs. Thomas Harris introduced us to a man who we were not supposed to love. A man who enjoys a glass of Chianti with a plate of human liver and fava beans is not the ideal dinner guest, but there is just something appealing about him. Lecter may be a serial killer who cannibalises his victims, but he also displays a high degree of intelligence and charisma. Lester is a man who is able to dissect us mentally. He understands the workings of the human mind and he knows what makes us tick and isn’t that all that we want? To be understood.

The Poet

The Poet is a serial killer created by Michael Connelly and who we first meet in his first Jack McEvoy novel, called The Poet. The Poet is the ultimate manipulator. He kills with an ice-cold precision, successfully manipulates us and he also quotes poetry. The Poet almost seduces us both with his dedication to his work and his ability to keep one step ahead of those who are pursuing him. The Poet is a man who can literally walk amongst us. What’s not to love about him?

Tom Ripley

The Talented Mr. Ripley had to make the list. We follow Tom Ripley from New York to Rome, Venice and Greece but it takes us a little while to accept that we’re following the steps of a serial killer. All of that glamour but so much murder. Tom Ripley charms the people around him and he charms us. How could we not emphasise with a young man who’s just trying to make his way in the world? Surely, we can overlook the murders, the duplicity and deception? The appeal of Tom Ripley is that we almost justify his reasons for murder and that is scarily irresistible.

Norman Bates

Norman Bates is the serial killer that we never saw coming. He looks like your next-door neighbour. Norman is the nice man who would help you carry the heavy IKEA boxes from your car and offer to build your wardrobes. We genuinely like Norman and there’s no way that he would kill his mum; would he? Norman Bates is the perfect serial killer because he leads us into a false sense security and plausible deniability. Norman Bates is our first introduction to a killer who has a split personality, and he forces us to ask the question of whether there is good and evil in all of us. We can almost convince ourselves that the murderous acts of Norman Bates are not his fault and that we can definitely blame it all on ‘mother.’ 

Nadine Matheson’s addictive and chilling debut crime novel The Jigsaw Man is out now, available from your local independent bookshop, Bookshop.orgHiveWaterstones, and Amazon..

Other Articles

The Imperfect Art of Baking by Jessica Ryn

This week is National Baking Week, and to mark the occasion Jessica Ryn has joined us on the blog to share a delicious gingerbread recipe like the one Violet Strong – the protagonist in her uplifting new novel The Imperfect Art of Caring – bakes with her mum. Happy… Read More

Alice Feeney on the inspiration for her novel and book recommendations

Dear Reader, I first had the idea for Rock paper Scissors during a trip to Scotland in 2018. We drove to a remote property in a terrible storm, which they called the Beast from the East. When we finally arrived it was dark, there was no power and our phones didn’t… Read More

Don’t be a kittenfish: 6 dating terms you need to know!

Last Girl Ghosted, the latest gripping psychological thriller from Lisa Unger, is out now! To celebrate, Lisa joins us to teach us the language of (modern!) love… Do you know what breadcrumbing is?! You meet someone through a dating app. And it seems to be going well. You… Read More